Several weeks ago, I attended the Wizards of Web seminar with Bryan & Jeffrey Eisenberg outside of Austin, Texas, at the Wizard Academy. It was a great event to be sure. Roy Williams, the Wizard of Ads, warned about being sensitive to the BS meter when developing online copy.
This is something that I have been wanting to blog about for some time now. Perhaps I have let it slide -- until I found a company and industry that I know well. No matter what online industry you look at online, there seems to be at least a half dozen who claim to be industry leaders per category. Do marketers think they can get away with this? It barely passes the laugh test anymore. It’s obnoxious unless it can be substantiated.
That leads me to Market Wire’s (remember Internet Wire and GINA) latest release. I would rather not even entertain it here, but it does illustrate my point. Let’s see… where do I begin with this one? Let’s start with the first paragraph of the release:
“Market Wire, one of North America's largest newswires, and a full-service distributor of company press releases and material news, announced important industry milestones today for its revolutionary press release optimization solution, SEO Enhanced.”
Okay, you ready? Here’s my analysis with the BS meter on “stun”:
“One of North America’s largest newswires”
Okay, I guess that is all in how you measure large. And you can pretty much claim to be one of anything relating to your industry. I will give them a pass here.
“… revolutionary press release optimization service”
This is frankly where they lose me. Especially in the context of the following sentence:
“Since SEO Enhanced was launched one year ago…”
I guess if we define “revolutionary” as finally “showing up” close to a decade after a movement has started, we could give them a pass. But frankly, that hardly passes my test for revolutionary. To be truly considered revolutionary one must contribute to the discussion and community. There are others who supported us when this was new and revolutionary. Greg Jarboe of SEO-PR, Lee Odden, Mark Effinger and many others all joined PRWeb in the discussion and evangelism of SEO press releases.
Furthermore, Market Wire appears to have “borrowed” SEO principles from PR Newswire, which was essentially modeled after PRWeb, v1.0. What do they say about a copy of a copy? (See the movie “Primer” for a less than subtle hint). Bottom line: it is less of a Market Wire revolution than a Market Wire “catch-up.”
Now for some real fun. Let’s look at the second paragraph.
“Since SEO Enhanced was launched one year ago, it has been used in thousands of press releases, on behalf of companies representing 137 different industries. Use of SEO Enhanced has grown from less than 1% of Market Wire's monthly release volume to nearly 6%, with nearly 30% of the company's SEO Enhanced releases being delivered for publicly traded companies. To date, over 10% of Market Wire customers have used SEO Enhanced with nearly 40% of those customers using it more than once. SEO Enhanced users include small privately held and Fortune 500 companies alike. Recently, Fortune 100 technology giant IBM agreed to SEO-enhance more than 200 of its press releases.”
What would the identical paragraph look like if it were used to talk about PRWeb’s SEO program? Alright, just to make it easy on you, I’ve taken the guess work out of this exercise and filled in the blanks for you. (I took out the bit about IBM as n/a to PRWeb. I also removed references to growth in this space because we launched the service with SEO; therefore it is not relevant.)
“Since PRWeb SEO was launched nine years ago, SEO technology has been used in nearly 400,000 press releases, on behalf of companies across 250 different industry targets. Use of PRWeb SEO has been used by over 170,000 customers including a CA-based communications company of a Market Wire founder. To date, 100% of PRWeb customers have received some level of the PRWeb SEO service. PRWeb SEO users include small privately held and Fortune 500 companies alike.”
Here are just five reasons why I am not worried.
- PRWeb is Revolutionary -- We choose to lead and not follow.
- The traditional wire service model prevents companies like Market Wire from taking full advantage of true SEO. I would be more specific but will decline to do so in this forum. Why give them the blueprint.
- While other wire services have their eyes focused on SEO, we have moved the cheese. SEO alone is not going to get the job done anymore.
- The community knows who pioneered this space. The community has invested in the PRWeb platform and adopted our vision.
- Our users are loyal.
Regardless of their marketing we welcome Market Wire to the game.
As always, open for comments. -- David
Recent Comments